A series of posts in response to reviews of
“Rewriting Hisstory.”
The following posts take advantage of the Web’s unique ability to provide a writer with an open and flexible space to respond quickly and thoroughly to criticism and in this case, “commentary.” The non-linear format also affords me the freedom to address issues when and how I see fit to do so, without the fretting over space and deadlines which tend to shorten the lives of even the most prolific journalists.
-
John Earl Haynes Just Can’t Handle the Truth
First it was Harvey Klehr and now John Earl Haynes (in the Journal of Cold War Studies) with failed hits on “Rewriting Hisstory.” Clearly, they are the academic version of “The Gang That Couldn’t Shoot Straight.” Click here for a detailed response to Haynes’ 51-page “review,” that makes one thing… Read more.
-
“Last Soldier Standing”
by David Chambers the Washington Examiner, July 5, 2025. Nearly every historian worth their salt thoroughly researches and contemplates their subject. Eventually, they make a judgement call on a person’s character and the choices made by the individual or group. Finally, the historian places the story in context. That’s why… Read more.
-
Response to “The Big Kisseloff”
by Harvey Klehr, Commentary, April 16, 2025. Klehr: Part One: The review by Mr. Klehr was neither unexpected nor surprising. Typical of Klehr’s reviews, it 1)relies on personal attacks against someone who simply disagrees with his conclusions; 2) ignores evidence new and old that casts doubt on the information from… Read more.
-
“Sherlock Holmes and the Hiss Case”
Invoking the creator of Sherlock Holmes for solving the Hiss case is not entirely facetious, but clearly needs some explanation and background. With his aid, it can now be said that Whittaker Chambers lied about the crucial aspect of his story that Alger Hiss, as a mid-level State Department bureaucrat,… Read more.
-
“Is ‘Hisstory’ History?”
by John W. Berresford Self-published, 131 pp. (Yes, it’s true); December 2025. I don’t know whether to be honored or horrified by John W. Berresford’s astounding 131-page diatribe against Rewriting Hisstory. His heels are dug in so deeply, that he refuses to accept a single new finding in RH’s 392… Read more.
