Mario Mendoza will forever be attached to a .199 batting average, the standard against which all mediocre Major League hitters are compared. Every player knows he won’t last long if he doesn’t cross the Mendoza Line.
This was driven home to me recently when I completed a response to a 137-page review of “Rewriting Hisstory” only to be told that a 57-pager had just been published in this space. Taken together, they were 194 pages of mostly insults.
Because it was written over a period of half a century, “Rewriting Hisstory” presents a great deal of new information and evidence. I sued the FBI for an unredacted set of Hiss files which amounted to some 115,000 pages. I also scoured the country for the personal papers of the key players in the case. I found scores of personal letters between Alger and Priscilla Hiss from the early 1930s. I interviewed the case’s last living participants and long before then constantly peppered Hiss with questions about the old and new allegations against him. I even conducted experiments on the original Woodstock typewriter 230099 and visited the Hisses’ former homes where the espionage allegedly took place and spent countless hours reading and discussing the new evidence from the Russian files.
On the other hand, neither Haynes or the other reviewers take any of the revelations seriously. On their scorecard, I was batting .000. Mario Mendoza was Babe Ruth compared to me.
Or do they? It seems to me if they really feel the book is as worthless as they say, they wouldn’t spend so much energy attacking it. The book must scare them.
What follows are just a few of the many important findings that emerged over five decades of work on “Rewriting Hisstory.”
1) There was and is no evidence of Hiss’s radicalism. At the trials, it was pointed out that he had worked with the journal of the International Juridical Association, but as the FBI learned in its interview with the journal’s editor, Shad Polier, Hiss was asked to join the editorial group because he wasn’t a radical not because he was. Scores of private letters between Alger and Priscilla from the late 1920s through 1933 show that neither one developed radical politics during that period when the government and some historians claimed both had moved to the left.
2) Rep. Richard Nixon and HUAC investigators Robert Stripling and Ben Mandel knew all along that Hiss not Chambers was telling the truth before HUAC when Hiss said he knew Chambers as George Crosley, which meant that Chambers was pretending to be a journalist and was not introduced to Hiss as a Communist operative, as he claimed.
3) The Hisses’ neighbors on 30th Street never heard any typing even though they could hear everything else inside each others’ tiny homes. Chambers, who said he was a regular visitor, had no recollection that Tim Hobson had broken his leg and was bedridden during this period. Tim told me he had a vague recollection of Mrs. Chambers but never met her husband. My own typing tests revealed that the typewriter was plenty loud enough for the sound to pass through several rooms, which means it would have been heard in the houses next door.
4) Whoever typed up the documents repeatedly omitted material that would have been of genuine interest to the Russians. The writer Ella Winter said she was approached by Chambers in the 1930s and asked to steal documents for him and even laid out a reliable method for doing do. My own examination of the typing and the handwritten corrections suggest that someone else besides Priscilla Hiss typed and corrected them.
5) Ben Mandel and Isaac Don Levine tried to destroy Hiss’s career over a dozen times from 1939 to the HUAC hearings in 1948. The motivation for those hearings was explained out in a memo that Mandel wrote that spring to show that the Democrats were weak on Communism. FBI files and the correspondence between Mandel-Levine documented their efforts.
6) Basic testing by me of Woodstock 230099 in comparison to more than a score of other Woodstocks of similar vintage, strongly suggest that the typebars on 230099 had been altered. It was the government’s position that the soldering of the type to the bars generally resulted in uneven connections like many of those on 230099. The defense’s expert offered a different opinion, saying that the Woodstocks he examined all had very even soldering. My collection of 20 Woodstocks showed the same.
7) The government presented testimony it knew was false, including that of Chambers’ maid Edith Murray, who said the Hisses visited the Chambers’ home; it concealed statements from the defense, including a184-page statement produced over four months leading up to the trial. The statement concludes with the FBI showing Chambers photos of people he said he worked with in the underground. He was unable to identify many of them. Afraid of the implications, the government concealed the existence of that statement from the defense.
Both Chambers and his wife lied repeatedly when testifying against the Hisses before the House Un-American Activities Committee (Esther was not a HUAC witness), the grand the jury, in depositions and at both Hiss trials.
8) The release of Allen Weinstein’s papers, covering his research for “Perjury” shed a harsh light on his work. I also found that when the information in the recently released Russian files could be checked against known events, the information did not match up. Hiss was said to have been a spy code named ALES in a cable released under the Venona project, but an analysis of that cable showed that it wasn’t Hiss. The FBI also couldn’t identify Hiss from the same cable either. An interview with Russian spymaster Vitaly also revealed problems with the documentary evidence.
Despite all this and quite a bit more, Mark Kramr After I absorbed all that evidence, and weighed the contradictory material, it seemed clear to me that Hiss was innocent. If Hiss did not produce the documentary evidence someone else did. I then listed all the likely candidates and the reasons why they could or couldn’t be “the doers,” as they call them on TV police procedurals, eliminating them one by one until the clear candidates emerged.
This had nothing to do with loyalty to Alger, to Tony Hiss, to the left or anyone. It was loyalty to the truth, which was drummed into my head in journalism school and years of work as a reporter and editor. It was a conclusion I came to by weighing the evidence on both sides and deciding which was right.
It wasn’t just Haynes. Despite the presentation of considerable new evidence and the synthesizing of the older material into the case. The editor of the Journal called the book “woefully inadequate,” without any explanation. He then goes on to describe me solely as someone who ‘worked for Hiss, as if that defined my entire 50 years of working on the case
For Haynes, these are findings are a challenge meant to be batted down. Having familiarized myself with all of Haynes’s (and his frequent writing partner Harvey Klehr’s) writing on the case, going back three decades, Haynes’s review fits perfectly within the pattern of his previous work, where two common traits are: 1) the refusal to accept any new research that suggests Hiss might have been innocent as the truth and 2) personal attacks against the author or source, aimed at diminishing them, their skills and intelligence in the eyes of the reader.
Historical accuracy is not something he seeks. I don’t have any explanation for what at first appears to be sloppiness but on subsequent reads appears to be a deliberate attempt to distort the record, other than to think that to Haynes, Hiss’s guilt exists to fit his world view. The narrative he tells isn’t based on facts; the “facts” he presents are, however, based on the narrative.
As distressing as that is, however, even more concerning is the acceptance of the narrative by other members of the history community. Anyone who thinks otherwise is an outlier or as Haynes and Klehr put it in their 2003 book, “Historians, Communism and Espionage”, they are liars.
And right there is the crux of the problem. Criticism is to be expected. It is healthy and democratic and the debate over research and results and the ideas and conclusions that come from it is what makes academia so important to a free society.
There is nothing healthy about having John Haynes (or Klehr, for that matter) review a book that concludes Hiss was innocent. The distance between “anyone who disagrees is a liar” to “oops” is just too vast.
Haynes’s caustic attitude which permeated his 1990s work along with his repeated manipulation of the facts, show that he long ago became the prosecution’s equivalent of the German Shepard tied up in the gas station office at night, ready to pounce without reason on anyone who intruded on his narrative. Any suggestion based on solid information or a well-grounded hypothesis will always have the same result — Haynes or Klehr, flat out refusing to consider it and instead just gnawing on your leg.
About the only thing that isn’t the target of Haynes’s sarcasm is my name, but then again his partner Harvey Klehr took care of that with his review, “The Great Kissoff” in Commentary. The level of rudeness by Haynes is such, that I almost get the feeling he doesn’t like me. But what Haynes clearly doesn’t realize is the sarcasm and the insults can come back to bite you. If he is looking to establish his credibility, stating that Julius and Ethel Rosenberg died in a gas chamber, frankly, doesn’t inspire a lot of trust.
That whopper is in “The Long Goodbye of Alger Hiss, a 1996 obit of sorts, published by Heterodoxy. Yet, in the same story, he not only attacks those who disagree with him, but he blithely complains about what he sees as the inaccuracy of other historians.
In “The Long Goodbye” Haynes offers up a list of people he says confirms Chambers’ story that he was a spy and Hiss was a member of the underground. These include Chambers (confirming Chambers), along with other alleged spies, photographers. None of these stories are literally true; there are holes in all of them and Haynes knows this but he’s gambling that the readers don’t. All of them are important here, though, because we see the beginnings of the pattern that continues in his review of “Rewriting Hisstory.” Since in the current review Haynes is asking readers to trust his interpretation of documents that only he and a few of his colleagues have seen, it is not only fair but also imperative to look at his current and past work to see if he has earned that kind of credibility.
I don’t think he has. While some of his mistakes are the minor kind that everyone makes, most are clearly errors of omission or distortions intended to rewrite the narrative of the Hiss case.
For example, Haynes writes that Franklin Vincent Reno, a brilliant mathematician at the Aberdeen Proving Grounds confessed to being a member of Chambers’ spy ring. People confess to all sorts of things under pressure from prosecutors who will threaten a much longer sentence if the case goes to trial and it ends in a conviction. Reno was charged with concealing his past membership in the Communist Party on his job application. That, he did do.
As far as being a member of Chambers’ spy ring, just because Chambers was collecting documents, doesn’t meant mean he was actually sending them on to anyone. This is where the Reno story is instructive.
Haynes scoffs at Reno whose story is one of the saddest in the entire affair. Haynes just can’t understand what pushed Reno, a brilliant mathematician, to conceal his former Party membership. He just can’t believe that a former Communist might lie on an application for patriotic reasons, but that’s what Reno did, so he could help with the war effort as a mathematician, knowing he would never have been hired to his ability had he revealed he had once been a Party organizer.
Living across the hall from Reno was Herman Louis Mayer, a future mathematics professor at the University of Chicago. Through his door, Mayer could hear Chambers demanding material even though it was apparently after the date that Chambers left the Party. If he didn’t turn anything over, Mayer recalled him saying, he would turn Reno over to a federal agency.
In rebuttal, Haynes offers a totally irrelevant description of the potential importance of such tables. More to the point was the interview in Meyer Zeligs’ “Friendship and Fratricide” with Mayer who said Reno finally put an old obsolete firing table in an envelope just to get rid of Chambers. “There was nothing important or secret about them; they lay around the Proving Grounds like toilet paper in a washroom.” Zeligs thought this was Chambers just collecting his life preservers. Much of the documentary evidence Chambers produced against Hiss was similarly useless.
Haynes also says that three photographers confessed to photographing for Chambers. This is just a small part of the story; the rest is damning — for Chambers. Felix Inslerman was one, and he too was alive when Haynes was doing his research. I was able to speak to his widow. Chambers said Inslerman worked for him for about a year; Felix Inslerman said it was more like five times. His wife agreed. There was a strong indication that it was Inslerman who was telling the truth. When Chambers was asked to identify Inslerman during his grand jury appearance, he picked out a local Baltimorean named Sam Pelovitz who had nothing to do with the case and didn’t resemble Inslerman at all. Inslerman, who told a different story about how the documents were returned, had no idea what if anything Chambers was doing with the film.
The second photographer, William Edward Crane, was being groomed to testify against Hiss, but he disagreed with Chambers on so many aspects of Chambers’ story that Crane had to be sent home. He talked about sources who Chambers never revealed, other houses where the work was done and entirely different methodology for picking up and delivering materials. To claim they both confirmed Chambers’ story again without explanation is just more Haynes’ irresponsibility.
As for the third photographer who confessed, I have no idea who that was. Chambers claimed that David Carpenter did photography for him, but Carpenter pleaded the Fifth, so I confess I’m in the dark about that one.
Haynes says in both the obit and the review that Hede Massing, who the FBI called “a Viennese woman with a doubtful reputation,” also confirmed that Hiss had been a member of the underground. Massing is prominent in the Russian files but her statements to the FBI and in her book repeatedly contradict what she said previously to the Russians, to the Bureau, or to anyone. For example, regarding her story from the second Hiss trial about competing with Hiss for the services of Noel Field as an underground Communist agent, she quotes Field as saying, “Why should I join your group when there is someone else in the State Department who is doing the same thing?” — a reference she said to Hiss, but Field and Hiss did not serve in the State Department at the same time. In another statement, she has Field already in her group, while Alger is trying to poach him.
Massing was also contradicted by both Herta and Noel Field. After her husband disappeared, Mrs. Field signed an affidavit for the defense saying that the meeting that allegedly took place in her apartment never happened. After he was released from prison, Field also disputed Massing’s story. When I talked to his brother-in-law, Leonard Doob, about Field (who was kidnapped and held in solitary confinement behind the Iron Curtain and tortured for years) naming Hiss while still in prison, he said that Noel told him he would say anything if he thought it might help him. Haynes cites “This Deception” as an accurate source even though parts were rewritten by the FBI. These are only a few of the contradictions. If Haynes wants to dispute them, fine, I can respond, but to pretend they don’t exist is irresponsible.
In the review, Haynes basically repeats his comments about the Russian historian Dmitri Volkogonov, who issued a statement in 1991 that after checking certain files, he concluded that Hiss was not a spy.
This, of course, resulted in outrage among the right wing. In Haynes’s view, Volkogonov then put an end to the controversy by backing off the statement, saying he was just trying to do a favor for an older man.
Haynes adds that Volkogonov was unable to search the files of the GRU, or Russian military intelligence. “As serious students of the case know, Chambers and Hiss worked for the GRU espionage network.”
As any serious historian would know, the phrase should read “allegedly worked.”
In the review, his account regarding Volkogonov is essentially the same as the one in “The Long Goodbye.” Volkogonov did a subsequent interview with John Lowenthal, however, in which he stated:
“…we also asked to examine the military intelligence files and there, too, no traces of Alger Hiss have been found. Sometimes I’m told that I could look through not all of them, and naturally I can’t say that I’ve seen all existing documents, but the intelligence documents pertaining to agents, personnel matter I did see. And it is also possible that he had some regular working information in the course of normal contacts he might have said something, but it was not intelligence information.”
None of this made it into “The Long Goodbye”or the review.
It’s hard to move from “they are liars” to “maybe we were wrong,” so it’s no surprise that Haynes’ most biting comments are reserved for any new examination I conducted. “He recounts how he taught himself to be an expert technical document examiner…” The fact is I don’t suggest this at all. It’s merely that after 75 years, modern equipment can give us new insights into the typewriter and documents. One doesn’t have to be an expert to turn on a recorder or peer through the lens of a modern professional level microscope and maybe photograph something that couldn’t be spotted as well on a microscope 75 years ago. But one does have to be open to different answers. It’s the first time I can recall an academic criticizing intellectual curiosity, but it tells you a lot. Curiosity is the friend of anyone digging for the truth. Accepting the established wisdom without even wanting to test it, is decidedly not. Or, as they told us on our first day of journalism school, “If your grandmother says she loves you, check it out.”
Before Haynes accuses me again of being one-sided, I should mention that much of my research didn’t make it into the book but that doesn’t mean I didn’t spend sometimes years examining allegations both against Hiss and Chambers. Weinstein’s allegations and papers alone set me back a couple of years as I looked into each of his most important charges, not knowing what the results would be. The documents I used are posted on rewritinghisstory.com. Haynes knows this because he accessed them.
As for Haynes’s own evenhandedness, the Heterodoxy obit doesn’t include a single positive comment about Hiss’s long life and work. There’s nothing, for example, about the cotton contract Hiss helped write when he was with the Agricultural Adjustment Administration, which for the first time would pay poor and mostly black sharecroppers directly instead of being dependent on white landowners to distribute payments equitably. You won’t read about Hiss’s role in establishing the United Nations as secretary general of the San Francisco conference, nothing about his sharp questioning of witnesses on behalf of the Nye Committee investigating excess profiteering during World War I. At the same time, in his discussion about whether Donald Hiss was a member of the Party, Haynes says nothing about Donald being instrumental in saving the lives of thousands of Romanian Jews during World War II.
Haynes flings so many allegations around the obit that one really does need a scorecard to keep up with them. The pro-Hiss books are “polemics.” The co-author of “In Denial” would never resort to polemics. Too often, he gets so many things wrong in the current review that it feels like he hasn’t read the book. His complaint about polemics leaves me wondering whether he has read his own.
Much of the criticism of Allen Weinstein’s work was ‘vicious” and later he calls it “nitpicky” because it doesn’t in his view go to the heart of the case. He writes that the attacks “take on some small narrow issue, claim that an error has been found and that, therefore, the entire book should be disregarded.” This is pretty funny, in light of the fact that later in his review he attacks my credibility by spending several pages trying to exploit a transcription error that led me to call Michael Intrator a Trotskyite instead of a Lovestonite. Suddenly, this is big stuff, according to Haynes
Haynes specifically says in the review that I, unfairly used a much later acknowledgement of sexual assault to cast aspersions on Weinstein’s work. Haynes forgets though that it was Weinstein who made his character center to his personal narrative: he presented himself as a liberal with a conscience. When he saw the evidence lined up against Hiss, he had no choice, he said. In defending Weinstein, he is also trying to protect someone who wrongly called a source of a murderer and then tried to excuse it by blaming someone else.
Weinstein also hid his notes for 19 years and when they were finally released under pressure from a group of historians who objected to his appointment as Archivist of the United States. The notes told a much different story.
Opposite of being reluctant, he prepared scripts, laying out negative responses to Hiss’s efforts to clear himself and also to address Lowenthal’s documentary which was about to be released, hoping to destroy any positive response they got. In addition:
He promised Priscilla Hiss a fair interview but never gave her the chance to defend herself against the charge that her strong Socialist views (which she never had) were a major reason why her husband moved to the left.
Weinstein refused to give Donald Hiss, who he accused of orchestrating the Woodstock coverup (which Garry Wills said convinced him that Hiss was guilty), the time to respond to charges.
He repeated a false story about Priscilla Hiss admitting covering up her husband’s work for the Russians. The story was so outrageous the book’s publication had to be delayed so it could be removed.
As for Weinstein’s character, while researching a report about how Chambers arranged for documents to be stolen, he repeatedly asked out Sally Belfrage, the journalist whose father Cedric Belfrage, Weinstein would label a spy (as did Haynes and Klehr). Sally Belfrage shut down the unwanted advances by Weinstein, who was married at the time.
In a brief section of the review, entitled “Kisseloff’s Failed Attempt at Alternative Explanations,” Haynes dismisses out of hand my own theory, a sympathetic one, about how being a closeted gay man in the 1930s, could have driven some of Chambers’ efforts that he attributed to Communism. Maybe Haynes knows more about human sexuality than I do, but I find it odd that Chambers could turn off homosexuality to coincide basically to when he claimed to have joined and left the Communist underground.
He also denies Chambers was a scammer even though Chambers laid out the scam clearly in his long statement to the FBI.
As to whether Chambers was a spy, “Rewriting Hisstory” offers considerable evidence that he was not, for example:
- He claimed the Ware Group was kind of the jumping off point for him, yet people who acknowledged being in the group, which they said was merely a reading group for members of the party, said they hardly saw him at all. Also, Chambers made up the name, “The Ware Group.” Members called themselves The Cling Peaches.”
- His methods of pick-up and delivery of documents from the Hisses was disputed by Hiss’s stepson Tim Hobson and the Hisses’ neighbors. Espionage experts said his methods violated Soviet spycraft.
- He would tell friends about his activities as a spy. “He was the most unsecret spy you can imagine,” according to David Zablodowsky.
- The handwritten notes in particular were alarming to Vitaly Pavlov, the head of espionage services in North America, beginning in 1929. Pavlov told us they would never accept information like that because of the danger of it being misconstrued.[1]
A footnote in the review refers to a question I asked him at a conference at NYU. He mischaracterizes my response as triumphant; it was more like shock. Judging from the audience’s gasp, I wasn’t alone. After he spoke about the importance of Hede Massing who was quoted extensively in the Vassiliev notes I asked him why they didn’t put what she said in context, mainly all the contradictions in her story, which raised questions about her truthfulness. He basically said it wasn’t their job, which was to name names. Adding context was the job of others.
I found his response sad and dangerous, maybe a little lazy and certainly inimical to learning the truth, especially when it comes to the Russian files which beg for context.
Throughout the review, Haynes appears to take a dim view of journalism and journalism techniques. Although I have spent considerably more time studying the case than Haynes or anyone he cites has, he suggests that I have no right to criticize those he calls scholars and their scholarly articles because I’m out of my element.
For example, he defends the historian G. Edward White who in his book, “Alger Hiss: The Looking Glass War” sees nothing wrong with Nathaniel Weyl’s claim that in the summer of 1933 he was in the Ware Group (he also didn’t know it’s real name) with Hiss. White just apparently invents this idea that Hiss was somehow bored with what he thought was the slow pace of the New Deal. I pointed out that this was during the FDR’s famously productive 100 days, so the idea of Hiss being bored, only a few months into his job, sounded a bit silly to me.
Haynes responded that I didn’t know how the CP worked. This is irrelevant since Hiss wasn’t a CP member, so whatever knowledge Haynes says he has is irrelevant. Besides if he had bothered to contact Hiss at any point, I’m sure he would have heard very quickly that the first 100 days of the New Deal were among the most exciting of Hiss’s life.
And as far as my not understanding the CP, which he says hated the New Deal, I can read. In his memoir, John Abt, a longtime Party member, said the group used to send reports to the Party leaders about New Deal legislation to get the Party behind it, not oppose it.
As a journalist and historian, you learn quickly that the human element of any story is crucial to understanding its true nature. The human element is also missing from Haynes’ account and when it appears in mine, it seems to make him uncomfortable. Chambers’ life as a closeted gay man must have been terrifying for him in the 1930s, hence my speculation that the apartment of William and Anna Spiegel might have been a safe haven for him to be with other men. It clearly wasn’t what he claimed it was for – a place to do photography as the Spiegel’s testimony was airtight that it couldn’t have happened and it didn’t happen. Their son reiterated to me that they were saying the same thing privately.
Over the years, Haynes could have picked up the phone and called Tim Hobson, or Felix Inslerman or William Edward Crane for clarification. Tim would talk to anybody but there’s that danger of a live person ruining a good story. That Chambers had no idea Tim was bedridden for months in the Hiss’s tiny 30th Street house during the time Chambers said he was a regular visitor to the house, should raise huge questions about the Russian files if they say he was an agent during this period. When I asked Tim why the other side should believe him, he answered, “I didn’t love them enough to lie for them.”
Elizabeth May’s clear recollection of not hearing any typing from the house next door should do the same. Later, a sportswriter moved into the house, and his typing on deadline kept them up at night.
Haynes’s ignorance about the Hisses’ life in Washington during the early days of the New Deal leads him to make another false assumption. He finds Hiss’s generosity to Chambers in allowing them to spend several nights at their home to be not indicative of the casual relationship that Hiss claimed it to be. But that’s what the Hisses did. They regularly opened their homes to newcomers to Washington who were seeking work in the New Deal. That was just who they were.
Haynes says David Zablodowsky confessed to be a mail drop for Chambers, but that’s not an accurate description, and Haynes knows it. He lays out what happened in John Lowenthal’s documentary. The story is similar to Oliver Edmund Clubb’s whose chance meeting with Chambers shattered his career. Clubb is also in the documentary. He also told his story in his memoir, “The Witness and I.”
Regarding other issues:
Haynes says that on August 7, Chambers gave HUAC many examples of inside knowledge he had about Hiss and his family, but what he doesn’t say is that the overwhelming number of statements were wrong.
Haynes says Hiss lied about his 1929 Ford car that he turned over to Chambers to give to a “poor organizer out West,” Chambers said. But the signature of William Rosen on the transfer was forged, Rosen had been tossed out of the Party years before and owned a dry-cleaning store in Washington DC.
In another bizarre accusation, Haynes writes that I imagine a conspiracy in 1938 from 1948, that nothing happened during that time to suggest there was any plot to destroy Hiss’s career. I just don’t know how to respond to this except to point out that that the FBI files track every single one of their attempts, beginning I suppose with the evening at Adolf A. Berle’s home in 1939.
In discussing the 1939 meeting between Assistant Secretary of State Adolf A. Berle and Levine and Chambers, Haynes writes that Chambers identified Hiss as a secret CP member but not necessarily as a spy but that espionage was implied. This was not at all how Berle characterized it. He said the two brothers were seen as targets for recruitment and espionage was specifically denied.
At this point, Haynes begins to get confused. He seems so eager to denigrate the idea of a conspiracy he places individuals from a previous section of the book into it. Leonore Byrnes Fuller was the first person to label Hiss a dangerous radical when the two were both working for the Agricultural Adjustment Administration. Hence, I mention her in a small section that explains why Hiss may have been called a Communist by people of influence in DC. Haynes says since she didn’t call him a Communist, she didn’t have much influence and it’s basically wrong to include her in the conspiracy.
Well, yes, that may have been one reason, the other would have been that she died before the conspiracy came together.
Regarding the actual conspiracy itself, which Haynes calls “preposterous”, among other things, I mentioned the following points:
1) Since Hiss had no motive to participate; wasn’t a Communist and neither was his wife; since no one actually heard her typing the documents; since the documents seemed randomly collected and typed without paying attention to their contents, and. Since Chambers lied about key points in their relationship, the central question becomes, “someone produced these document, if Hiss didn’t, who did? Who could that have been? Creating a negative list to eliminate a host of candidates, it came down it left two people standing: Isaac Don Levine and Ben Mandel, both of whom had already been trying to destroy Hiss’s career for ten years when Chambers testified publicly for the first time.
2) It most likely wasn’t a grand conspiracy, as Haynes refers to it sarcastically, which is the reason why it succeeded; the fewer the people the better.
3) The secrecy meant that neither I nor anyone knows for sure how it was carried out. I simply point out that this is one way it could have been pulled off, by showing how it fit in neatly with known facts about the people who were the likely participants. More important than how it was done, was the fact that Hiss didn’t do it.
All these misstatements and strange assumptions by Haynes feel not so much like he doesn’t know better but rather he doesn’t want to know, so how can we trust his interpretation of documents that only a few have seen? The answer is, we can’t.
Had I more space here, I could go into more detail, but I will have to do so at the book’s Web site, rewritinghisstory.com. There I can also cover other issues raised in the review.
I’ll end with one more story. According to Vassiliev’s notes, Hede Massing was the handler of Laurence Duggan, a State Department official and Latin American expert. Duggan died when he fell out of his office window (some claim he was pushed, others said he jumped) in December 1948. About ten years ago, I wrote to Duggan’s son to ask him what he thought. He in turn sent me a large envelope stuffed with handwritten letters between Duggan and his wife, mostly written during the last year of his life. The letters were full of detail (they apparently had a healthy sex life) but there was nothing in them indicating any illegal or even questionable activity, nothing indicating unhappiness over any undue pressure or that he was being threatened in any way.
One tale Massing told was being sent to see Duggan at his home about his underground work. She got there during the son’s birthday party. After sitting for a long time, she left.
In 1969, Bill Reuben visited Mrs. Duggan. One of her distinct memories was of the day that the FBI had gone to see him a few days before he died and asked him about several people, including Hede Massing. When he got home from work that night, according to Bill’s notes, he wanted to know who she was. His wife then reminded him that she was that woman who showed up at the birthday party and then went home.
Haynes closes his Heterodoxy piece by complaining about Hiss case scholars who refuse to accept the inevitable, but then he says, “Historical scholarship…is only of value if it is a search for the truth. Anything else is a fraud.”
Finally, something on which we can agree.
[1] The first four exhibits in the Baltimore documents were handwritten notes on slips of paper. The handwriting on Exhibit one was especially atrocious and Hiss said it was possible it wasn’t his. In Haynes’s opinion, this was Hiss covering up; the topic about the Robinson Rubens affair had nothing to do with his work and would have been of interest to the Russians. I asked Hiss about this, and he said it was front page news, of course Sayre was interested. As for the handwriting, Haynes omits or forgets that when the FBI’s document expert Ramos Feehan saw it, he was also unsure whether it was in Hiss’s handwriting.
